By Alric Lindsay
Scott Garrett Butler appeared before Magistrate Gunn this week to be sentenced for conspiracy to supply ganja, conspiracy to possess firearms, possession of unlicensed firearm (ammunition) and threats to kill. However, Magistrate Gunn delayed the sentencing until January 2025 until further information can be obtained from Butler’s medical treatment provider overseas.
Why Butler is receiving overseas treatment
Regarding Butler’s treatment for drug addiction in Canada, it is understood that the services he requires are not available in the Cayman Islands. This includes certain outpatient services and injectable administration, which he takes periodically in Canada.
Complex diagnosis poses challenges for sentencing
According to Butler’s lawyer, Oliver Grimwood, Butler’s complex diagnosis and treatment means he may have to travel back and forth to Canada.
In the circumstances, Butler’s lawyer asked Magistrate Gunn to consider imposing a suspended sentence without conditions. This would allow Butler to return to Canada for treatment.
Regarding this request, Magistrate Gunn noted that “the mental health team were concerned that Mr Butler was not active at the residential facility where it was meant to be.” That is, it appeared that Butler may not have been living there or attending there completely.
As a result, Magistrate Gunn said the Court needed to see more details from Butler’s treatment provider before considering the matter further.
Sentence delayed
Initially, Magistrate Gunn extended Butler’s bail to October 23, 2024, noting that if he failed to return, a warrant would be issued for his arrest. However, Butler’s lawyer requested that the date be revised as Butler is leaving Cayman this weekend and is not expected to return until December.
Since the Courts close for holidays in December, Magistrate Gunn said the sentencing would be delayed until January 13, 2025. By then, she should have received reports from Butler’s treatment provider in Canada detailing his diagnosis, suggested treatment, and participation in the treatment program. Any request for a suspended sentence, i.e., no prison time, will be considered at that time.
