November 22, 2026

Editorial Ethics and Publishing Principles

These are the standards BlackBox Insights holds itself to. They are written down so that readers can hold us to them too.

Accuracy comes before speed

We would rather publish second and be right. Where a fact cannot be confirmed before deadline we either leave it out or say plainly that it is unconfirmed. When we use “reportedly” or “it is understood” it is based on facts stated by a party.

We report what was said, and we say where we got it

Court reports are drawn from proceedings heard in open court. We attend hearings in person, or remotely by video link with the permission of the court. Where a quotation appears in quotation marks, those are the words that were spoken, taken from our contemporaneous note. Where we are paraphrasing, we do not use quotation marks.

Fairness to people we report on

We publish what was said on the record in open court or at a public event, and what is contained in documents obtained from public authorities, including responses to requests under the Freedom of Information Act. Where a person or an organisation is named, it is because they were named on the record in one of those settings. We do not publish an allegation that reaches us privately and has not been tested in open court or in a public document.

We distinguish, in the text, between what a court has found, what a party has asserted, and what we have concluded. An allegation made by counsel in open court is reported as an allegation made by counsel in open court.

The presumption of innocence

A person charged with an offence has not been convicted of it. Our reports say so where there is any risk of confusion. We report acquittals and discontinuances with the same prominence as we reported the charge, and a verdict of not guilty entered on a judge’s direction is reported as what it is — a full acquittal.

Children, complainants and reporting restrictions

We identify no child involved in criminal proceedings. We identify no complainant in a sexual offence case, and that protection is not affected by the outcome of the trial. We take active care over jigsaw identification: in a jurisdiction of this size, a combination of details that seems harmless in isolation can identify someone, and we edit for that risk rather than assume it away.

Where a court has made an order restricting reporting, we obey it. Where we think an order is wrong, the remedy is to apply to the court, not to publish.

Sources

We honour undertakings of confidentiality given to sources, and we do not give such undertakings casually. Anonymity is granted where a source faces a real risk — of dismissal, of prosecution, of harm — and not merely to allow someone to criticise a rival without attribution. Where a source is anonymous we tell readers why, and we tell them enough about the source’s position to weigh what they are saying.

We do not pay for information. We do not obtain material by deception or by misrepresenting who we are, save in the rare case where a matter of clear public interest cannot be reported any other way, and then only with the editor’s prior authority.

Conflicts of interest

We disclose, in the article, any interest that a fair-minded reader would want to know about — a personal or professional connection to a party, a financial interest, or a role held elsewhere. Where the conflict is significant, we do not run the story.

We accept no payment, gift, hospitality or advantage from anyone we report on beyond ordinary courtesies of no material value. We do not accept payment to publish, to omit, or to alter coverage. Advertising has no influence on editorial decisions and no advertiser sees an article before publication.

Comment and analysis

Analysis is labelled as analysis. Where we express a view — for example that a delay in the courts warrants explanation — it is set apart from the reporting of fact, and it is founded on the facts set out in the same article. We criticise institutions and conduct; we do not conduct campaigns against individuals, and we do not use a person’s misfortune as material for public shaming where nothing turns on it.

Use of technology

Automated tools may be used to assist with routine drafting and organisation of our own notes. They are not a source of fact.

Images

We do not alter photographs beyond cropping and ordinary adjustment of tone. Where an image is an illustration rather than a record of the event described, it is captioned as such. We do not photograph inside a courtroom.

Responsibility

The editor is responsible for everything published. Complaints are dealt with under our Corrections Policy.

Last reviewed: 25 August 2026.