November 18, 2026
2:02

By Alric Lindsay

A 41-year-old man accused of pushing a passenger off a recreational boat at Starfish Point has pleaded guilty to common assault. The Crown has confirmed it will withdraw the more serious charge of assault causing actual bodily harm when he is sentenced.

Jeffrey Elroy Tutor entered the plea in Summary Court today, November 17, 2026, before Magistrate McFarlane. He admitted assaulting Benjamin Esguerra at Starfish Point on January 25, 2026.

Tutor’s defence counsel told the court the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) had indicated it would withdraw the charge of assault causing actual bodily harm (ABH). Crown Counsel Wedderburn confirmed the ABH count will be withdrawn at sentencing.

The court heard that Tutor has no previous convictions and that his work permit runs until July 2027. The Magistrate did not order a pre-sentence report. Tutor’s bail was extended to January 13, 2027.

Background

As Blackbox Insights reported on October 6, the charges arise from a boat excursion aboard the Sweet Romance at Starfish Point, North Side, at around 4.30pm on Sunday, January 25, 2026.

It was alleged that Esguerra, then 54, was standing at the edge of the lower deck, preparing to jump into the water again, when a man beside him pushed him from behind. He fell uncontrolled and struck his head.

Esguerra reported a bleeding mouth, loose teeth, a bruised forehead and severe neck and shoulder pain. He was taken to the Health Services Authority’s Accident and Emergency Department for a CT scan and was referred for extensive dental treatment.

Police arrested Tutor, a Filipino national, on February 23, 2026. He was originally charged with ABH under section 216 of the Penal Code, with common assault under section 215 as an alternative count.

Tutor returns to court on January 13, 2027.

Leave a Reply