November 22, 2026
9:25

By Alric Lindsay

The prosecution’s case in the Centennial Towers attempted murder trial lay in absolute tatters today, October 29, 2026.  A relentless chronological onslaught by a formidable line-up of defence King’s Counsel pointed to systematic witness coaching, wiped cell phones, hidden back-channel plea deals, and a startling admission that police turned off recording devices right before their star witness launched into volatile unrecorded statements.

Senior investigating officer Detective Inspector Joseph Wright faced a devastating forensic slaughter before Hon. Justice Emma Peters today. Leading the defence onslaught in strict chronological succession were prominent King’s Counsel Rhiannon Sara Crimmins KC, Brendon Kelly KC, and George Carter-Stephenson KC. By the evening adjournment, the credibility of the Crown’s star immunity witness, Jimmal Facey, was thoroughly shattered.

Case Background: The Centennial Towers Ambush

To provide context for readers following this high-stakes trial, the case stems from an alleged, coordinated, near-fatal gangland ambush executed in February 2025 in the parking lot outside the Subway restaurant at Centennial Towers in West Bay. Gunmen unleashed a hail of six shots targeting Jiffon Robinson and Denver Bright, shattering storefronts and causing widespread panic.

The Royal Cayman Islands Police Service (RCIPS) initially said an interlocking web of co-conspirators orchestrated the hit over an ongoing dispute that began at the Jungle Bar. However, the case took an extraordinary legal turn when primary suspect Jimmal Facey flipped, securing an absolute immunity agreement from the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). Since then, Facey’s shifting testimony has become the trial’s main battleground.

Rhiannon Sara Crimmins KC: Prison Leaks, Cell Fire, and “Tailored” Testimony

Opening the chronological defence attack, Rhiannon Sara Crimmins KC systematically targeted DI Wright’s complete disregard for record-keeping protocols. Crimmins KC exposed that during a critical early visit to interview Facey on March 20, 2025, DI Wright failed to bring any audio or video recording equipment or his official police notebook.

In stark contrast, on April 24, DI Wright physically entered the prison facility entirely alone with a pre-written, formal witness statement for Facey to sign. The lead detective admitted under oath that he took absolutely no contemporaneous notes or electronic recordings during this meeting. More damaging still, Crimmins KC pointed out an inconsistency in DI Wright’s approach.  He initially told Crimmins KC that he did not bring his notebook to the March prison meeting because of concerns that other prisoners would raise suspicions; however, he had no issue bringing a confidential witness statement for Facey to sign in April.

The cross-examination took a bizarre turn when Crimmins KC questioned the detective about a January 13, 2026, interview session. DI Wright claimed total amnesia regarding the operational purpose of the meeting, muttering: “I cannot exactly recall.” He indicated that the transcript could probably clear that up.

When Crimmins KC pressed him on whether the emergency visit was tied to an investigation into a fire maliciously set inside Facey’s own prison cell, DI Wright became defensive: “It is not an allegation. Someone did set a fire. It was a CID investigation and not a CTF [Crime Task Force] investigation.” He could offer no logical explanation as to why he was conducting further case inquiries that day if it fell outside his task force’s remit.

Crimmins KC then proved that DI Wright did not check if Facey had watched the plaza CCTV footage before taking his revised statements about Austin Crawford.  Crimmins KC highlighted that Facey’s account about what Crawford allegedly did at Centennial Towers changed between two dates. Crimmins KC asked DI Wright if he did not think Facey’s change of account was unusual.  Before deflating under pressure, DI Wright said: “Based on your suggestion, I agree.”

Crimmins KC went into more detail about the structural shifts in Facey’s story.  In Facey’s first interview, he did not mention who burned clothing after the incident.  However, in the second interview, Facey offered up Crawford as the person who burned the items.

Brendon Kelly KC: Secret Plea Bargains and the “Scrapped” Car Illusion

Following Crimmins KC, Brendon Kelly KC, representing co-defendant Jamie Ebanks, shifted the focus sharply onto the back-channel legal machinations used to secure Facey’s cooperation. Kelly KC produced an explosive chain of internal email correspondence from March 2025 between Facey’s then-lawyer, Jonathan Hughes, and Crown Counsel Scott Wainwright.

The documents proved that immediately after Facey was locked up on attempted murder charges, Hughes appeared to lobby the DPP to substitute the charge with mere possession of an imitation firearm to trigger an immediate bail release. Hughes told prosecutors that the police “would no longer be of the view” that Facey fired shots. When confronted with an email where Hughes claimed the detective explicitly agreed that attempted murder was inappropriate, DI Wright angrily deflected: “This was incorrect. These were never my words. He is trying to entertain Mr Scott Wainwright in a certain direction.”

Kelly KC then grilled the detective on whether he had communicated his personal agreement to Facey’s steep demands. The court heard that Facey had made his terms crystal clear: he wanted absolute immunity from prosecution, an immediate exit from prison, and safe relocation out of the Cayman Islands. Kelly KC demanded to know why follow-up interviews were conducted under the shadow of these unrecorded demands, suggesting the police quietly aligned with Facey’s narrative just to secure their star witness. DI Wright conceded he was fully aware of what Facey stood to gain by feeding information to the police but claimed the final immunity evaluation rested with the DPP.  Immunity was not a decision made by the police.

George Carter-Stephenson KC: Witness Rambling, Unrecorded Statements, Unchecked Witnesses

Concluding the chronological defence gauntlet, George Carter-Stephenson KC launched into a blistering attack on the selective deactivation of police recording gear, persons spotted on CCTV camera driving and walking near Boggy Sands Road, but never interviewed as witnesses.

Regarding the tape recording, Carter-Stephenson KC revealed that at the conclusion of an official session, DI Wright asked Facey if he had anything to add. When Facey said no, DI Wright turned the recording equipment off. Immediately after the device was shut down, Facey began rambling and crying.  DI Wright admitted he consciously chose not to turn the recorder back on, keeping the violent breakdown completely off the electronic record.

Finally, Carter-Stephenson KC played raw security footage on the courtroom monitor, catching the police in a total investigative blind spot. The footage clearly showed a vehicle reversing on a part of Boggy Sands Road while two individuals walked toward the seawall, remaining stationed there for a considerable period. While they were standing at the wall, the suspect Honda Odyssey drove directly past them.

Crucially, as the two individuals began walking away from the seawall on foot, the camera captured at least one of them turning his head sharply to the right, visually tracking the exact path and direction where the Honda Odyssey had gone.

“If you were aware two persons were there, wouldn’t you want to speak to them?” Carter-Stephenson KC thundered.

DI Wright responded, saying that they were not persons who could be readily identified and he was uncertain what they could have seen from the seawall.  No attempt appears to have ever been made by the RCIPS to identify or track those individuals as potential witnesses to the arrival at the attempted murder scene and getaway. This appeared to be an important piece of the puzzle because, instead of finding these witnesses, Facey was relied upon by police to give the only account of what happened on Boggy Sands Road.

Carter-Stephenson KC then exposed a massive physical contradiction that the police completely failed to investigate. Facey had initially claimed his car was safely parked in a driveway near Kelly’s Bar. Yet, when an RCIPS search team went to locate it, the vehicle was completely gone. Rather than investigating a manufactured alibi or a conspiracy to destroy evidence, DI Wright admitted he blindly accepted Facey’s hand-waving explanation that “my car was scrapped,” writing it off as an unverified assumption.

Further, Carter-Stephenson KC noted that Facey told the police that Facey’s phone could be opened by Face ID. When Carter-Stephenson KC queried DI Wright whether he asked Facey to open the phone, DI Wright said, “No.”

Lastly, Carter-Stephenson KC asked DI Wright if he was aware that one of Facey’s phones was reset to factor settings. DI Wright said, “Yes,” and indicated that Facey’s phones were sent to the police’s cyber crime unit. DI Wright did not indicate whether the cyber crime unit was able to retrieve anything from the phone that was reset to factory settings.

The Grand Court trial stands adjourned until October 30, when additional witnesses are expected.

Leave a Reply