
By Alric Lindsay
A fiery legal battle is brewing ahead of a high-priority Summary Court trial next month, as a local defence attorney Stacy-Ann Kelly demanded access to internal police disciplinary records and injury photographs, promising to level severe cross-allegations against the Royal Cayman Islands Police Service (RCIPS).
Oshane Chakoya Johnson appeared before Magistrate McFarlane today, October 29, 2026, to secure a fixed trial date for two allegations of assaulting an officer and one allegation of resisting an officer.
His defence attorney noted that Johnson previously pleaded not guilty to the charges and she launched a robust application for extensive digital disclosure to prepare her client’s case. Kelly requested that the Crown immediately turn over high-resolution digital photographs detailing the physical injuries Johnson sustained during the encounter, alongside comprehensive Records Management System logs from the time of the arrest.
Crucially, Kelly took her application a step further by demanding the internal disciplinary files and complaints history of the specific police officers involved in the arrest. She informed the court that the disclosure is vital to the defence’s strategy, as they intend to lodge formal cross-allegations against the police force, bringing the conduct and credibility of the arresting officers directly into question during the trial. According to Kelly, Johnson was “assaulted” and “punched in the chest.”
The court also heard arguments regarding Johnson’s personal circumstances. Kelly highlighted that while her client maintains an “on-time” status for local immigration purposes, he is currently entirely destitute and without any form of employment.
Citing his financial strain, Kelly pushed hard for a December trial slot. In the circumstances, Magistrate McFarlane marked the case down for a high-priority trial on November 24, 2026.








